Bring a Trailer vs. Cars & Bids: Which Fits Your Car?

The two biggest names in online enthusiast car auctions are Bring a Trailer and Cars & Bids. They look similar, but the buyers and the cars are different.
Bring a Trailer
Bring a Trailer started in 2007 as a blog and grew into the largest online collector car auction site. In 2025 it reported more than $1.7 billion in sales across nearly 50,000 auctions, with an 81% sell-through rate. It covers everything from pre-war cars to modern ones, with strong demand for classics, air-cooled Porsches, vintage trucks and SUVs, and well-kept originals.
Cars & Bids
Cars & Bids was founded by Doug DeMuro and focuses mainly on modern enthusiast cars, typically from the 1980s onward. Its audience skews toward newer performance cars, sporty hatchbacks, modern trucks and special editions.
Similarities
- Roughly week-long timed auctions
- Public comment sections where buyers ask questions and spot problems
- Late bids extend the clock, so the ending can run long
- Curated listings: neither site accepts every submission
How we decide
We look at four things:
- Age and type. Older and classic cars tend to suit Bring a Trailer. Newer enthusiast cars can do well on Cars & Bids.
- Audience. Where do people already search for this model?
- Recent results. What similar cars sold for on each site.
- Timing and fees. Each site has different fees and review timelines.
Other options exist too, including Hemmings, PCarMarket for Porsches, and in-person auctions like Mecum. The right answer depends on the car, which is why we start with a free valuation and recommend a platform afterward.
One honest note
Site rules, fees and the types of cars each accepts change over time. We check current details for each car instead of relying on a general rule.
Common questions
Which is better, Bring a Trailer or Cars & Bids?
Neither is better for every car. Bring a Trailer covers a very wide range, with strong demand for classics and originals, while Cars & Bids leans toward modern enthusiast cars.
How long do the auctions run?
Both typically run about a week, and late bids extend the clock so the ending can run longer.
Who decides which site to use?
We recommend one after a free valuation, based on the car, recent sales and each site's fees and timing. The final choice is yours.
Jack Ploszay is the founder of PCAP Motors in North Falmouth, Massachusetts. He helps owners across Massachusetts, Rhode Island and New Hampshire sell collector and enthusiast cars at auction, with certified vehicle appraisals and detailing through the same team. About PCAP · (774) 521-6027
What is your car really worth?
Free valuation, no obligation. We tell you honestly whether an auction makes sense for your car.